
These four men have been charged after a home invasion on Saturday night in James City County. Clockwise, from left: Christopher Allen Williams, Devonte J. Hayes, 21-year-old Marklin Antonio Mitchell, 21-year-old D’Andre Andrews Hardy. (Photos courtesy James City County Police Department)
The four men accused of a violent home invasion in the Lafayette Village apartments off Longhill Road in James City County on Saturday night have differing accounts of what happened.
A set of criminal complaints filed against the men in Williamsburg-James City County District Court reveals that investigators talking to the suspects after their arrests were unable to get any of the men to say who shot a man in the apartment. The victim, who was shot in the back of the head, was taken to MCV Hospital in Richmond and is expected to survive.
According to the complaints, the shooting victim said he heard someone kicking in the door of the apartment and then saw four men wearing bandannas come into the residence. He said they started “beating” on everyone and demanding everyone’s money and phones. Maj. Stephen Rubino of the James City County Police Department said five people ranging from ages 16 to 22 and two young children were in the apartment when the incident occurred.
Another person in the apartment said he saw four to six men break into the apartment and that he hid in a closet. He said he heard them breaking stuff and asking for money. He said it then got quiet and that he went out to find the shooting victim.
A third person in the residence said five men wearing blue bandannas broke into the residence and that he was thrown to the ground, kicked in the ribs and punched in the head. He said a man then put a shotgun to his head and took his phone, wallet and ID.
A fourth person in the residence said he saw two men come into the apartment and that he was hit with a chair and knocked to the ground. A table was then thrown on top of him. He said he heard the intruders saying “give me the money” several times.
A fifth person in the apartment said she was watching TV when she heard two kicks on the door. She then saw four or five men enter the house. One of them put a pillow over her face and told her not to look in their direction. He said she felt a gun at her head as the men demanded money. She said the demands continued and that she then heard a gunshot. She heard what sounded like fighting before someone yelled “okay, okay let’s go.”
Another witness in the apartment complex reported seeing a gold Ford Taurus in the parking lot and that several armed men were standing by it putting on masks. That witness was able to provide a license plate number to police.
Officers from the James City County Police Department found the vehicle in the parking lot of the 7-Eleven on Pocahontas Trail about an hour after the incident occurred. Police initiated a traffic stop and found 21-year-old Devonte J. Hayes of Williamsburg and 21-year-old Marklin Antonio Mitchell of White Plains, N.Y., in the vehicle.
Police then determined that Hayes and Mitchell were at a residence on Algonquin Trail before leaving for 7-Eleven. Police went to that residence and found 21-year-old D’Andre Hardy of Williamsburg — he owns the gold Ford Taurus — and 21-year-old Christopher Allen Williams of Williamsburg. Those two men, who were found outside of the home, were then arrested.
During their interrogations, the men told different stories, according to the complaints.
Hardy said he was “chilling” at his house with “Mark, Devonte and Chris.” He said he was dropped off along with Williams at The Happy Shopper and that Hayes and Mitchell left with the Ford Taurus. He denied being in the area of Lafayette Village.
Hayes said he was hanging out with Hardy, Mitchell and Williams and that the four drove around and went to the Grove section of James City County. He also denied being in the area of Lafayette Village.
Williams said he was hanging out with Hardy, Hayes and “some other guy whose name he did not know” at Hardy’s home, according to the complaint. He said they then went out in the car and ended up at Lafayette Village. He said he got out with Hardy to use the bathroom and that both got back in the car. He said one of the men had a shotgun with him but that he could not say who. He denied being inside the apartment during the incident.
Mitchell said he was hanging out with the other three at Hardy’s house. He said they did go to Lafayette Village and that he was standing at the door when the others went inside. He described the interior of the apartment to police but stayed at the door. Mitchell said he went to buy marijuana and it all “turned real bad.” He then said he heard a gunshot and everyone took off running.
Rubino said Wednesday the men are alleged to have stolen some money, jewelry, cell phones and possibly other property. Police continue to try to piece together exactly what was taken from the apartment. He said investigators are also trying to determine if another victim was in the apartment who ran out before police arrived.
At least some of the alleged home invaders knew some of the people in the residence. When asked if anyone besides the four men were involved in the alleged home invasion, Rubino said the case remains under investigation.
The four men will appear in Williamsburg-James City County District Court at 2 p.m. Feb. 20.
Related Coverage: